Inelastic Decay from Integrability (2024)

PRX Quantum

a Physical Review journal

Highlights
Recent
Accepted
Authors
Referees
Search
About
Scope
Editorial Team

Open Access

Inelastic Decay from Integrability

Amir Burshtein and Moshe Goldstein

PRX Quantum 5, 020323 – Published 29 April 2024

Article
References
No Citing Articles

PDFHTMLExport Citation

Abstract

Authors

Popular Summary

Article Text

INTRODUCTION

MODELS AND OBSERVABLES IN A cQED SETUP

OVERVIEW OF MASSLESS INTEGRABLE QUANTUM…

THE TOTAL INELASTIC DECAY RATE AND…

THE ENERGY-RESOLVED INELASTIC DECAY…

CONCLUSIONS

ACKNOWLEDGMENTS

APPENDICES

References

Abstract

A hallmark of integrable systems is the purely elastic scattering of their excitations. Such systems possess an extensive number of locally conserved charges, leading to the conservation of the number of scattered excitations, as well as their set of individual momenta. In this work, we show that inelastic decay can nevertheless be observed in circuit-QED realizations of integrable boundary models. We consider the scattering of microwave photons off impurities in superconducting circuits implementing the boundary sine-Gordon and Kondo models, which are both integrable. We show that not only is inelastic decay possible for the microwave photons, in spite of integrability, and due to a nonlinear relation between them and the elastically scattered excitations, but also that integrability in fact provides powerful analytical tools allowing us to obtain exact expressions for response functions describing the inelastic decay. Using the framework of form factors, we calculate the total inelastic decay rate and elastic phase shift of the microwave photons, extracted from a two-point response function. We then go beyond linear response and obtain the exact energy-resolved inelastic decay spectrum, using a novel method to evaluate form-factor expansions of three-point response functions, which could prove useful in other applications of integrable quantum field theories. Our results could be relevant to several recent photon-splitting experiments and, in particular, to recent experimental works that provide evidence for the elusive Schmid-Bulgadaev dissipative quantum phase transition.

Received 10 October 2023
Revised 29 December 2023
Accepted 1 April 2024

DOI:https://doi.org/10.1103/PRXQuantum.5.020323

Published by the American Physical Society under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International license. Further distribution of this work must maintain attribution to the author(s) and the published article's title, journal citation, and DOI.

Physics Subject Headings (PhySH)

Research Areas

Integrability in field theoryKondo effectQuantum simulationQuantum transport

Physical Systems

Sine-Gordon equation

Techniques

Bethe ansatzLuttinger liquid model

Condensed Matter, Materials & Applied Physics

Authors & Affiliations

Amir Burshtein^* and Moshe Goldstein

Raymond and Beverly Sackler School of Physics and Astronomy, Tel Aviv University, Tel Aviv 6997801, Israel

^*Corresponding author: burshtein2@mail.tau.ac.il

Popular Summary

Integrability has become synonymous with purely elastic scattering. Integrable systems are defined by a set of quasiparticles that, because of a particularly large set of symmetries, maintain their individual energies and momenta in any collision process. A particular class of such systems, integrable quantum impurity models, that are composed of a waveguide coupled to an atomlike object, provide a great platform to probe those collisions directly. Current experiments have studied the scattering of single microwave photons off impurities in nonintegrable models, showing they can be split into multiple photons at a high rate; in integrable impurity models, one might be tempted to conclude that any trace of such inelastic behavior should be abolished by the strong symmetries. Strikingly, we explicitly show how the purely elastic scattering of the quasiparticles builds up an inelastic scattering of the photon.

This apparently contradictory result is fundamentally enabled by a nonlinear relation between the photon and the quasiparticles. In fact, we use this nonlinear relation, which is encoded in the matrix elements of the bosonic (photonic) operator in the basis of the quasiparticles, to calculate the exact scattering rates, both elastic and inelastic, of a single incoming photon. We then devise a novel method for the calculation of multipoint correlation functions in integrable systems and use it to obtain the exact distribution of the outgoing photons. The rates provide a much-needed quantitative description of ongoing experiments and in particular reveal the emergence of the elusive Schmid-Bulgadaev superconductor-to-insulator quantum phase transition, which has been the center of intense debate over the past few years.

Our findings, as well as our technical achievements, should pave the way for tackling other integrable systems, from cold atoms and strongly correlated electrons to high-energy physics.

Article Text

Click to Expand

References

Click to Expand

Issue

Vol. 5, Iss. 2 — April - June 2024

Reuse & Permissions

Authorization Required

Other Options

Buy Article »
Find an Institution with the Article »

Download & Share

PDFExportReuse & Permissions

Images

Figure 1
(a) An incoming photon with frequency $ω$ , injected from the antenna on the left and propagating through the transmission line in the center, may decay inelastically as it scatters off the impurity on the right, in spite of the purely elastic reflection of the fundamental excitations of the integrable models. Each photon may be represented as a combination of eigenstates composed of excitations ${| \vec{λ} ⟩}_{ϵ_{λ}}$ with types $ϵ_{λ}$ and rapidities $\vec{λ}$ , where the weights are determined by the form factors, $f_{ϵ_{λ}} (\vec{λ})$ , and the total energy of the excitations in each eigenstate, $ν_{λ} \sim \sum_{i} e^{λ_{i}}$ , is equal to the photon frequency $ω$ (for notation and definitions, see Sec. 3). The excitations scatter elastically off the boundary (quantum impurity), picking up phases determined by the reflection matrix $R_{ϵ_{λ}}^{ϵ_{λ}^{'}} (\vec{λ})$ , such that the outgoing combination no longer represents a single-photon state but, rather, a multiphoton state. The measured observables—the total inelastic decay rate $γ (ω)$ and the energy-resolved inelastic decay spectrum $γ (ω^{'} | ω)$ , as well as the elastic phase shift $δ (ω)$ (not depicted here)—all shed light on the fundamental properties of the impurity models. (b) Implementation of Eq.(1) with the bsG and Kondo impurities [Eqs. (3) and (5), respectively] in a cQED setup. The array of Josephson junctions and capacitors implements a high-impedance transmission line, due to the kinetic inductance of the Josephson junctions.
Reuse & Permissions
Figure 2
The total inelastic rate $γ (ω)$ and phase shift $δ (ω)$ for the bsG and Kondo models and several values of $z$ . The power laws at low and high frequencies are denoted on the plots. In the phase-shift panels, we plot both $δ (ω)$ and $π / 2 - δ (ω)$ or $π - δ (ω)$ (for the bsG and Kondo models, respectively). We use Eq.(48) to evaluate $r (ω)$ at integer $p = 1 / z$ and $r (ω) = r_{+ -} (ω)$ at noninteger $z > 1 / 2$ .
Reuse & Permissions
Figure 3
(a) The energy-resolved inelastic decay spectrum as a function of $ω^{'}$ , at several fixed values of $ω / T_{B}$ , for the bsG and Kondo models and $z = 1 / 3, 1 / 2$ . The diagrams used to evaluate the spectrum are listed in Appendix pp6. (b) The ratio between the left-hand side and right-hand side of Eq.(53) for both models and several values of $z$ . Note that the power laws of $γ (ω)$ are recovered by the sum rule for all $z$ .
Reuse & Permissions
Figure 4
The contributions of $f_{m}^{R}, f_{+ -}^{R}, f_{12}^{R}, f_{+ - 1}^{R}$ (the latter evaluated only for integer $p = 1 / z$ ) to the reflection coefficient of the free theory, $r^{0} = 1$ , given in Eqs. (44)–(47) with $ω \to \infty$ . Here, $\sum_{ϵ_{λ}}^{'} r_{ϵ_{λ}}^{0} = \sum_{m = 1}^{⌈ 1 / z ⌉ - 2} r_{m}^{0} + r_{+ -}^{0} + r_{12}^{0} + r_{+ - 1}^{0}$ ; the dips of $1 - \sum_{ϵ_{λ}}^{'} r_{ϵ_{λ}}^{0}$ are at integer $p = 1 / z$ , where $r_{+ - 1}^{0}$ is evaluated.
Reuse & Permissions
Figure 5
The weight of the contributions to the $z = 1 / 3$ spectrum, evaluated using the sum rule.
Reuse & Permissions